Content index
I’m pessimistic about climate change. Here, I want to explain why, using the data, and why that pessimism does not paralyse me. Quite the opposite.
For the first time, the average over the past three years has exceeded 1.5°C of warming above pre-industrial levels. Last August equalled the record for the warmest month ever recorded. Copernicus estimates that long-term warming will reach 1.5°C by the end of this decade, more than ten years earlier than expected. And under current policies, the United Nations projects 2.8°C of warming by the end of the century.
That is why I no longer ask whether we will exceed the limit we set in Paris. I ask when, and every year the answer is sooner. And that calculation does not even account for tipping points or how they could accelerate the process.
This is not a matter of opinion. Climate change is about physics and mathematics. In 1856, the American scientist Eunice Foote filled two glass cylinders, one with air and the other with carbon dioxide, and placed them in the sun. The one containing carbon dioxide grew hotter and took longer to cool. A hundred and seventy years have passed, and the physics has not changed. What has changed is the concentration of the gas: when Charles Keeling began measuring it in Hawaii in 1958, it stood at 313 parts per million. In May this year, it was 432 — 38% higher.
We have more and more data, from ever closer to home:
Depending on the scenario, sea level along the Basque coast could rise by between 50 and 80 centimetres by the end of the century.
And we must acknowledge the hardest truth: the sea will continue to rise for centuries, whatever we do. That is the inertia of the ocean, as the IPCC makes clear. What we can do, however, is understand how much it will rise and how quickly.
That is where our work comes in: developing more precise scenarios and providing evidence so that institutions can make decisions based on the best available knowledge. Through Urban Klima 2050, alongside the Basque Government and Ihobe, we are modelling flood risk along the entire Basque coast at high resolution for the first time. This is a collective effort, undertaken with BC3, universities, BRTA centres and our colleagues in Iparralde.
Uhinak also reflects this reality: for the first time, local councils have had two dedicated panel discussions at the conference. They are the first to see the sea advancing.
As scientists, we have a responsibility to carry out research and improve our models. But I believe our greatest responsibility is something else: to make the science heard. To tell society what we know, even when it hurts. And to do so every day, not just when we are invited to a conference.
Eunice Foote is a powerful reminder. A colleague read her work aloud in public, and for more than a century she was all but forgotten. What science does not communicate is lost. And when those of us who have the data remain silent, that silence does not stay empty: it is filled by fake news, paving the way for climate denial. And denial is very convenient for those who would rather do nothing.
That is why I asked those in the room, and now ask you, for two things:
Uhinak means ‘waves’. A wave has a property that fascinates me: the water barely moves; it is the energy that travels. It passes from one drop to the next, crossing an entire ocean.
That is what we need: a movement that passes from one person to the next until it reaches everyone, stirs our consciences and leads us to commit to leaving our grandchildren a more sustainable world than the one we are currently on course to leave them.
I remain pessimistic. But a scientist’s pessimism is a diagnosis, and a diagnosis helps us act.
Let Uhinak be the beginning of that wave.